J Datta: our answer is Article 141, how does it... ... Justice Yashwant Varma Case: Supreme Court Hearing- Live Updates

J Datta: our answer is Article 141, how does it affect your Article 21 right?

Sibal: that law cant be contrary to Article 124(5)

J Datta: it says take "such actions" it does not mean removal; inhouse procedure has been in place for 30 years, all judges are supposed to know and takes oath. They know. It doesnt say removal because it would be contrary to 124(5). The recommendation has to be less then removal and it would be initiation.

J Datta: Nedumpura, we will hear you. But first, how did you get the confidential report?

Nedumpura: its there on LiveLaw

J Datta: we will issue notice to Livelaw, we will ask you to file affidavit on how you got the report