Datar: they say, we will make the point of law but... ... Supreme Court Hearing-Presidential Reference On Timelines For Bills' Assent-DAY-8 : Live Updates

Datar: they say, we will make the point of law but it will not affect the decree. The jurisdiction under Article 143 is not to clarify or evaluate the correctness of the decision. Indira Sawney says 50% is the limit, they say it applies to promotion also, can you have reference to 11 judges? no. Remedy is Article 368. My submission is Article 143 is not a constitutional method to bypass Article 368.

Even in federal court, there was a case where it gave advisory opnion under GOI Act. High Court started following it as binding, federal court says it erred in following it as binding law. In Kerala Bill, J Das comments upon federal court's judgment. Nothing wrong. I am saying, natural recourses is a wrong law to say you can decide, indirectly making intra-court appeal. Either it goes by Dawoodi Bohra rule or constitutional amendment.