Sibal: what is the law in which inquiry takes place? there is no procedure set up- it will not go to the tribunal because only aggrieved person can go- this is judge being in its own cause and the property will not remain waqf property- I said this at the outset
Sibal: if its gov, designated officer will decide and when inquiry is going on, the character of waqf changes. if there is dispute with private property, it also goes- you are throttling
J Masih: is it relatable to the...
Sibal: its not clarified
Sibal: pls read 3(C)
CJI: in view of proviso, 3(r), the property will cease to be waqf property as according to you?
Sibal: it says- dispute or gov property- dispute might not relate to Gov but still it will cease to be waqf property
Sibal: every organisation is covered, if panchayat raises dispute, there is end to waqf.
Sibal: so, if third person raises dispute, it will not waqf property. See S. 3(fa) and 3(fb) definition of Gov property
Sibal: creeping acquisition of waqf properties
Sibal refers to different provisions
CJI: Mr Mehta said three propositions, it has become 10 now
Sibal: he will have 11 solutions