Live Law
2025-08-21 09:13:29.0
SG: in that case, if Governor sits, the solution does not lie here. It lies in political spheres- these are all political decisions and they are solved in democratic manner. This organ has protected fundamental rights, you are custodian, but there are problems not solvable by judicial but by political democratic process. There are constitutional functionaries responsible and answerable at least every 5 years
CJI: hon'ble Governor is not answerable to anyone
SG: Governor is the most vulnerable office, he can be removed for any reason..if something happens in judiciary, the system takes care of in the administrative side.
J Narasimha: constitutional immunity is clearly worded in what decision, why withhold has taken place etc and all these stand on footing that there is constitutional immunity but we are referring to procedure prescribed, in regards to this, where is the immunity? Kesari hind, says there is no question of deciding the assent. the inquiry into the constitutional process of granting or not granting or referring, whether immunity applies never ending is the question.