Singhvi: Nebam Rebia- the only exception to non-participation in the legislative process is the promulgation or ordinance-A.213.

I have serious objections because it turns over head the constitutional schemes [referring to Mr Mehta's arguments on justiciability]-even grant of assent can be subjected to judicial review by private parties- it can only challenge on vires of statute-it can't be based on allegations. These are all created controversies. Any bill challengeable by private party when it becomes an Act. After it happens, it is on usual constitutional grounds...none of this can involve challenge of assent by Governor or President-completely erroenous argument.

Equally fallacious is the prerogative power argument- we are republician constitution antithetical to such powers.

CJI: like Article 356