Sibal: Article 254-repugnancy-Parliament has a way out if they think its repugnant, they can immediately pass a law which is a constitutionally provided solution. So, the point is, there is a constitutionally provided solution, this is just a bogey to make such the bills of the legislature is not passed.

J Narasimha; bills not enjoying legislative competence may be assented and it is only in the later part the law has to be passed?

Sibal: you can't have executive becoming an impediment to the will of the people

J Narsimha: your argument is that it will only be tested in a court

Sibal: there are assumptions made that a law will be made on foreign policy etc but mylords can't deal with such situations...they say, don't refer to West Bengal, TN but refer to my facts