J Pardiwala: for all the foregoing reasons,

1. reservation of 10 bills is in contravention in Article 200 and declared erroneous

2. as a result, any consequential steps might have been taken on 10 bills equally erroneous

3. long period for which it was pending, and scant respect on decision of Punjab judgment, we are left with no choice to declare the 10 Bills deemed to have been assented in light of inherent powers